Per un calcolo “di qualità”: storia di una sfida qualitativa alla quantificazione, passando per la conoscenza
Conference Paper
Publication Date:
2023
abstract:
Starting from the case study of a 16th century palace in Parma, this paper aims to demonstrate how
a careful constructive survey, together with an accurate investigation of the historical evolution of
the building can, in certain cases, avoid the need to resort to invasive mechanical tests for safety
assessment. This challenge is based on the awareness, resulting from a long debate in the academ ic and scientifc felds, of the importance of the ‘knowledge path’ in the analysis of the structural
behavior of historic masonry buildings: the ‘qualitative understanding’ of the building – gained
through the direct and in-depth knowledge of the asset, the constructive features, the proportional
rules, the historical evolution, as well as the experience of recurring damage – is the basis for a
correct evaluation of strengthening interventions and, sometimes, unexpectedly, is even preferable
to numerical data. In fact, it is widely recognized, even in the normative feld, that standard global
modeling procedures and numerical calculations, valid for ordinary buildings, do not always ft
for historic masonry structures, which tend rather to be damaged by local mechanisms. In fact,
the path of knowledge, applied to the case study, which will be illustrated in this paper, allowed to
highlight the main vulnerabilities of the asset and therefore to focus on the direct investigations
only on the elements at risk, for which local interventions will be planned, respecting the principle
of minimum intervention.
a careful constructive survey, together with an accurate investigation of the historical evolution of
the building can, in certain cases, avoid the need to resort to invasive mechanical tests for safety
assessment. This challenge is based on the awareness, resulting from a long debate in the academ ic and scientifc felds, of the importance of the ‘knowledge path’ in the analysis of the structural
behavior of historic masonry buildings: the ‘qualitative understanding’ of the building – gained
through the direct and in-depth knowledge of the asset, the constructive features, the proportional
rules, the historical evolution, as well as the experience of recurring damage – is the basis for a
correct evaluation of strengthening interventions and, sometimes, unexpectedly, is even preferable
to numerical data. In fact, it is widely recognized, even in the normative feld, that standard global
modeling procedures and numerical calculations, valid for ordinary buildings, do not always ft
for historic masonry structures, which tend rather to be damaged by local mechanisms. In fact,
the path of knowledge, applied to the case study, which will be illustrated in this paper, allowed to
highlight the main vulnerabilities of the asset and therefore to focus on the direct investigations
only on the elements at risk, for which local interventions will be planned, respecting the principle
of minimum intervention.
Iris type:
3.1 Contributo in atti di convegno
Keywords:
strutture in muratura; fattore di confidenza; meccanismi di danno; monitoraggio; parametri qualitativi
List of contributors:
Ottoni, F.; Zanazzi, E.
Book title:
Conservazione, prevenzione, fruizione